Almost Historical

Any story that is told multiple times changes multiple times. Some details are lost, and other details are added. The more times the same event is recalled, the less accurate the retelling becomes, at least until a “final” version is recorded in a concrete format, such as a biography or letter. However, the emotional response to a traumatic event can also lower the precision of a witness’ account of an incident that’s being questioned. During war, soldiers were faced with life­or­death decisions on a daily basis, and their memories suffered for it. What they could remember, they would often expand on to make themselves seem more heroic, either by embellishing aspects or by completely twisting fact into wowing fiction. Many of the young men going into the war were looking to be glorified and immortalized by the brave acts that they would commit while facing the enemy. It’s difficult to believe that when these soldiers wrote journals, they wrote without considering how they might affect their legacies. Those involved in the war already had an idea of what the Western Front was supposed to be like, implanted into their subconscious by posters and newspapers back home, and it would take weeks of hardship and horrors faced before they would truly abandon this idealistic view of the experience that they had truly signed up for.

Almost Historical

Alecia LeBlanc

Grade 11

Mount Douglas Secondary School
Victoria, British Columbia

I'm fascinated by the idea that history is ever-changing as new information is uncovered.

Related Essays

  • Historian's use of Primary Sources

    Historian's use of Primary Sources

    Makaela Smithers

    Lions Bay, British Columbia

    I enjoy funny stories that appear within hard times that show us how people in the past coped in the face of adversity.

  • Censorship and Reliable Sources

    Censorship and Reliable Sources

    Marie Dai

    Shawnigan Lake, British Columbia

    I chose this question because I have always been curious about the process through which historians use to separate their material.

 
View all essays